Approximate
Condition Profile
MARVEL COMICS · 1/79 · NEWSSTAND
UNIT ECA-017141
MARVEL TALES #111
Marvel Tales #111 reprints Amazing Spider-Man #129, the first appearance of the Punisher
// Unit specification
| Publisher | Cover date | Era | Variant | Key attribute | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marvel Comics | January 1979 | Bronze | Newsstand | Reprints Amazing Spider-Man #129 (1974), the first appearance of the Punisher; not itself a first appearance | AVAILABLE |
// Copies in archive
| Unit | Grade | Variant | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| ECA-017141 | ~8.5 | Newsstand | AVAILABLE |
// Run position
// Condition analysis
Cover shows strong gloss and vivid color with sharp corners and no visible creases or tears. There is minor edge wear along the left spine edge and a faint bend near the bottom left corner. The UPC barcode box confirms newsstand edition; interior and back cover were not assessed.
// Valuation — market reference
| Bracket | Grade | Est. market value | Marker |
|---|---|---|---|
| LOW_RAW | 0.5 – 1.5 | $12 | |
| MID_RAW | 4.0 – 6.0 | $38 | |
| HIGH_CERT | 9.8 SLAB | $200 |
// Archive commentary
Marvel Tales #111, cover-dated January 1979, is part of Marvel's long-running reprint anthology that recycled classic Amazing Spider-Man stories for a newsstand audience a half-decade removed from their original release. This issue reprints Amazing Spider-Man #129 (1974), the story that introduced the Punisher, rendered by John Romita in the clean, dynamic house style that defined the Spider-Man title through the 1970s. The surrounding cast — Aunt May, Betty Brant, J. Jonah Jameson, Flash Thompson, Liz Allan, Mary Jane, and villain Doctor Octopus — round out the supporting continuity carried over from the original publication.
As a reprint, the book's market value is tethered to its host character's popularity rather than to first-appearance status, which remains fixed to the original Amazing Spider-Man #129. Certified population is modest and thin at the top: only three 9.8s recorded against fifteen census copies, with FMV climbing sharply from the mid-grade band (about $38 at 4.5-6.0) to $200 at the 9.8 tier, indicating a typical Bronze Age reprint curve where mid-grade copies are common and gem copies are scarce and disproportionately prized. Demand is driven primarily by Punisher completists and budget-minded Spider-Man collectors seeking Romita artwork without the cost of the source issue.
This title trades as an affordable entry point rather than a blue-chip key, appealing to collectors building thematic Punisher or Spider-Man reprint runs, newsstand-era completists, and dealers stocking accessible Romita art at low cost. Low- and mid-grade raw copies remain widely available and inexpensive, while high-grade certified examples command a real premium given the small top-of-census population, making 9.8s the primary area of collector competition within this otherwise workhorse reprint issue.
INQUIRE_ABOUT_THIS_UNIT
Institutional buyers, auction houses, and private collectors — direct line to the archive.
