Approximate
Condition Profile
MARVEL COMICS · 5/74 · NEWSSTAND
UNIT ECA-009718
MAN-THING #5
Gerber and Ploog's 'Night of the Laughing Dead' from Man-Thing's acclaimed Bronze Age run
// Unit specification
| Publisher | Cover date | Era | Variant | Key attribute | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marvel Comics | May 1974 | Bronze | Newsstand | — | AVAILABLE |
// Run position
// Condition analysis
Cover shows strong gloss and vibrant color with sharp corners and clean edges; spine appears tight with no visible stress lines or ticks in this photo. There is a slight bend/crease near the lower left edge and minor surface handling wear consistent with a well-preserved Bronze Age book. Book is in a protective sleeve which limits assessment of texture and any micro-defects; interior and back cover were not assessed. Cover date of May 1974 predates the direct/newsstand distinction, so no variant designation applies.
// Valuation — market reference
| Bracket | Grade | Est. market value | Marker |
|---|---|---|---|
| LOW_RAW | 0.5 – 1.5 | $4 | |
| MID_RAW | 4.0 – 6.0 | $15 | |
| HIGH_CERT | 9.8 SLAB | $250 |
// Archive commentary
Man-Thing #5 (May 1974) arrives in the middle of Steve Gerber's celebrated early run on the title, with art and cover by Mike Ploog, whose loose, moody linework did much to define the swamp-creature's gothic, melancholy tone. The story, "Night of the Laughing Dead," continues the adventures of recurring supporting cast members Richard Rory and Ruth Hart and introduces a clown-themed antagonist along with several one-story bit players. It does not carry a recognized first appearance or origin moment; its importance rests on being a representative chapter of the Gerber-Ploog collaboration that, within the same string of issues, helped set the stage for the series' eventual creative leap into introducing Howard the Duck as a supporting character.
Market activity for this issue tracks the broader pattern for solid but non-key Bronze Age Marvel horror titles: steady interest from Man-Thing and Gerber-run collectors and from admirers of Ploog's art rather than from speculative first-appearance buyers. Census data show high-grade copies, including at least one CGC 9.8, are scarce, but pricing has never approached the levels commanded by the title's genuine keys, such as Man-Thing #1's second Howard the Duck appearance. Demand is genre- and run-driven rather than character-driven, which keeps the book's value curve comparatively flat and predictable across grades.
Buyers for this issue are largely series completists, Bronze Age horror collectors, and Ploog art enthusiasts rather than key-issue speculators. Low-grade copies circulate through bulk lots and back-issue bins as inexpensive reading copies; mid-grade raw examples serve run-builders assembling the Gerber Man-Thing sequence; and the rare CGC 9.8 appeals mainly to registry-set collectors of the title, where scarcity supports a modest premium without the volatility seen in the series' recognized keys.
// Copies in archive
| Unit | Grade | Variant | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| ECA-009718 | ~8.5 | Newsstand | AVAILABLE |
| ECA-009828 | ~8.5 | Newsstand | AVAILABLE |
INQUIRE_ABOUT_THIS_UNIT
Institutional buyers, auction houses, and private collectors — direct line to the archive.
