Skip to main content
Tales of Suspense #17 front cover
~3.0 AI-Estimated
Approximate
Condition Profile
TALES OF SUSPENSE #17
MARVEL COMICS (ATLAS) · 5/61
UNIT ECA-026215

TALES OF SUSPENSE #17

Atlas-era sci-fi/monster anthology issue from the twilight of Marvel's pre-superhero period

SIG 3/10 Available

// Unit specification

PublisherCover dateEraVariantKey attributeStatus
Marvel Comics (Atlas) May 1961 Silver — — AVAILABLE

// Copies in archive

UnitGradeVariantStatus
ECA-026215 ~3.0 — AVAILABLE

// Run position

// Condition analysis

⚠ AI-Estimated / Approximate Condition Profile

This pre-1977 Silver Age issue shows significant wear consistent with a well-read Golden/Silver Age comic: multiple visible creases running through the upper right corner and along the spine area, a distinct diagonal crease crossing the Googam figure and into the lower right corner, and heavy spine stress with several small ticks along the spine edge. There is noticeable edge wear and minor chipping along the top and right edges, along with some surface wear/rubbing to the cover gloss and mild discoloration at the bottom left corner. The book is protected in a mylar sleeve, which shows a diagonal crease reflection but is not part of the book itself. Interior pages and back cover were not visible in this photo and were not assessed.

// Valuation — market reference

⚠ AI-Estimated values — approximate, not an appraisal
BracketGradeEst. market valueMarker
LOW_RAW 0.5 – 1.5 $34
MID_RAW 4.0 – 6.0 $123
HIGH_CERT 9.8 SLAB $15,000

// Archive commentary

Tales of Suspense #17 belongs to the run of Atlas anthology titles Marvel published in the years just before the company's shift to costumed heroes with Fantastic Four #1 later in 1961. Like its siblings Journey into Mystery, Strange Tales, and Tales to Astonish, the series specialized in short science-fiction and monster stories built around twist endings, drawn by the stable of artists then working for Stan Lee, with Jack Kirby a frequent contributor of cover art for the line during this period. The book predates any of the superhero identities the Tales of Suspense title would later be known for, arriving well before Iron Man's debut in issue #39, and its content reflects the anthology sensibility of the late 1950s and early 1960s newsstand market rather than any origin or first appearance of lasting significance.

The certified population is modest but not scarce at the low and mid grades, with the bulk of the 105 census copies clustered between 2.5 and 7.0, consistent with a comic that circulated as ordinary newsstand fare rather than one collectors sought out and preserved. Demand and pricing accelerate sharply once a copy clears the mid-grade range, a pattern typical of Atlas-era anthology issues where high-grade survivors are disproportionately scarce due to the era's paper stock and handling. The complete absence of any certified copy at 9.4 or above underscores that scarcity, and the small handful of copies at 9.0 and 9.2 have not generated recorded sales, leaving the top of the market effectively untested.

This is a book for completists of the Atlas/pre-Marvel anthology era and collectors building out the full Tales of Suspense run rather than a title driven by character or creator-specific demand. Lower and mid-grade copies trade as accessible, modestly priced reading copies, while the market for high-grade examples is thin and largely theoretical given the absence of any 9.6 or 9.8 certified copy; a discovery at that level would likely be treated as a landmark census event and priced accordingly, but current data offers no direct precedent for it.

INQUIRE_ABOUT_THIS_UNIT

Institutional buyers, auction houses, and private collectors — direct line to the archive.